Draft Grades: Texans

The Texans got their wish in the 1st round with Brian Cushing. He certainly fills a need, but I still don't like the pick. I think Cushing is overrated and won't be a great every-down player in the NFL. His athleticism isn't anything special and he's little more than a pass-rush specialist. He'll start from day one at strong-side linebacker, but I think the Texans will be disappointed with the selection in the long run. His former teammate Clay Matthews would have been the better pick.

Connor Barwin will likely begin his career at defensive end but I wouldn't be shocked to see him moved to linebacker some day. He's a tremendous athlete, but he lacks the strength to stay on the field at defensive end. He'll likely step in for Antonio Smith in passing situations.

Antoine Caldwell was a great third round selection. I wouldn't be shocked to see him win the starting job from Chris Myers.

Glover Quin was a reach in the 4th round. They certainly needed a cornerback, but I don't see how he solves the problem. He's a nickelback at best and likely will offer very little in 2009.

I'm not quite sure what to make of their selection of two tight ends. I don't understand how a team could have graded Anthony Hill higher than James Casey. I also don't know why they felt it was necessary to take two tight ends. They've already talked about moving Casey to fullback. He isn't an ideal fit there, but he's a playmaker and anyway they can get him on the field would be a wise decision. Hill will be the odd man out, I don't see him making an impact in Houston.

Brice McCain is a phenomenal athlete with elite speed. He's a candidate to play special teams, but I don't see him making an impact at cornerback.

Troy Nolan can be an adequate backup safety and special teams contributor. He was a safe 7th round selection, but doesn't offer any upside.

This was a confusing draft for the Texans. They got a few players that can make an impact, but not necessary players that were right for their system. Cushing will start right away and Barwin will fit into the defensive line rotation. However, they also appeared to enter day two without any real plan. It raises some questions about the ability of their front office. For a team on the brink of playoff contention this was somewhat of a disappointing draft.

Grade: B-